A Discursive Analysis of Popular Protest Within Contemporary LGBTQ+ Social Movements

BATES, Adam (2026). A Discursive Analysis of Popular Protest Within Contemporary LGBTQ+ Social Movements. Doctoral, Sheffield Hallam University. [Thesis]

Documents
38211:1446672
[thumbnail of Bates_2026_PhD_ADiscursiveAnalysis.pdf]
Preview
PDF
Bates_2026_PhD_ADiscursiveAnalysis.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives.

Download (2MB) | Preview
Abstract
This research examined how North American English-language news media discursively constructed LGBTQ+ Pride events and protests during 2020. This was a critical juncture when COVID-19 disrupted traditional forms of gathering and both Pride and BLM racial justice activism came together following the murder of George Floyd. Specific attention was paid to less visible transgender and queer identities. A synthetic approach integrating Discursive Psychology, Critical Discursive Psychology, and Critical Discourse Studies was employed to analyse ten purposively selected news articles. Drawing on queer and intersectional theory, the analysis examined linguistic devices, including categorisation practices, temporal framing, metaphorical constructions, and boundary-making strategies, attending to both micro-level discursive features and their macro-level ideological functions. Five major discursive patterns were identified, collectively constructing what the analysis terms 'Pride in flux'. These are: contesting authenticity through corporatisation, politicians, and celebrity as discursive antagonists; reclaiming Pride's radical roots through temporal framing and historical legitimation; intersectionality as a discursive frame for strategic coalition-building; the construction of police as a constitutive outside through historical continuity narratives; and embodied resistance employing corporeal metaphors and voice-amplification strategies. These patterns revealed sophisticated negotiations between celebration and resistance, inclusion and authenticity, and assimilation and radicalism within contemporary LGBTQ+ activism, demonstrating that media discourse actively constructs rather than simply reflects LGBTQ+ political possibilities. Four theoretical contributions have been developed through the analysis: 'banal heteronormativity', revealing how heterosexual assumptions are reproduced through routine unmarked linguistic choices in the media; 'intersectionality as meta-political strategy', demonstrating how intersectional discourse functions as an active rhetorical resource for constructing authentic activism; 'temporal authenticity', identifying how movements construct cyclical narratives of return to radical origins; and 'resistant capitalism', capturing how activists navigate commercial participation whilst maintaining political authenticity. The tensions identified throughout are not problems awaiting resolution. Pride is not a fixed entity but a discursively created and contested one, continually constructed and negotiated through the language used to represent it.
More Information
Statistics

Downloads

Downloads per month over past year

View more statistics

Metrics

Altmetric Badge

Dimensions Badge

Share
Add to AnyAdd to TwitterAdd to FacebookAdd to LinkedinAdd to PinterestAdd to Email

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item