Occupational pension schemes in Germany: Learning from other European countries.

PETERSILIE, Muriel (2026). Occupational pension schemes in Germany: Learning from other European countries. Doctoral, Sheffield Hallam University. [Thesis]

Documents
38104:1432141
[thumbnail of Petersilie_2026_DBA_OccupationalPensionSchemes.pdf]
Preview
PDF
Petersilie_2026_DBA_OccupationalPensionSchemes.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives.

Download (2MB) | Preview
Abstract
The objective of the present doctoral thesis is to explore the possibility of a more sustainable and acceptable occupational pension system (OPS) for Germany and how this might be promoted and implemented in the future. Based on the researcher’s work as a practitioner in various roles in the area of occupational pension schemes in Germany over approximately 15 years, several weaknesses in the system were identified, which is supported by existing literature. The research objective of the present doctoral thesis is to explore these weaknesses further and to reflect on a system that could be more effective in the German context. The research applies a pragmatic philosophical standpoint using mixed methods to answer the research questions. The qualitative part follows the quantitative one, whereby the qualitative part comprises the main component of the research. The quantitative part is a macroeconomic comparison between Germany, France and the United Kingdom, serving to show the gaps Germany might have in terms of OPS. Additionally, four regression analyses with constructed datasets were conducted, focusing on Germany only, to simulate what might happen if things remain unchanged. The qualitative part is a case study on OPS in the German chemistry sector and analyses semi-structured interviews (SSIs) which have been conducted with stakeholders (employee, employer and trade union perspectives) of the German chemistry sector to find possible reasons why these gaps arise in the German OPS.

Key findings:

It appears beneficial to make occupational pension schemes compulsory and to introduce a matching system like in France or the United Kingdom. However, complexity should be reduced to ensure employees’ understanding and ultimately their uptake in occupational pension schemes.

The contribution to theory:

The trends from the literature review were confirmed, sometimes contradicted, and also expanded on. The study advances economic knowledge by extending the assumptions of the Lifecycle Theory (LCT) with insights from Behavioural Economics (BE), showcasing how structural, behavioural and cultural dimensions shape occupational pension outcomes.

The contribution to practice:

This research provides actionable guidance for policy makers and employers in Germany, demonstrating that by simplifying occupational pension schemes, strengthening employer contributions, reinforcing state intervention and starting financial education early in school, significant improvements can be made.

Keywords:

Occupational pension schemes (OPS), rewards, employee retention, compulsory occupational pension scheme, state pension scheme, matched-financed pension scheme, employer-financed pension scheme
More Information
Statistics

Downloads

Downloads per month over past year

View more statistics

Metrics

Altmetric Badge

Dimensions Badge

Share
Add to AnyAdd to TwitterAdd to FacebookAdd to LinkedinAdd to PinterestAdd to Email

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item