SAWYER, Robert (2023). A professional development programme for teaching mathematics through problem solving. Doctoral, Sheffield Hallam University. [Thesis]
Documents
32687:626710
PDF
Sawyer_2023_PhD_ProfessionalDevelopmentProgramme.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives.
Sawyer_2023_PhD_ProfessionalDevelopmentProgramme.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives.
Download (3MB) | Preview
Abstract
This thesis documents the design, implementation and evaluation of a professional learning
programme to support teachers in developing their ability to teach mathematics through
problem solving. Teaching mathematics through problem solving is recognised as an
effective way to teach mathematics. However, there are a number of different approaches
with different descriptors such as problem posing and problem-based learning. In this study,
teaching mathematics through problem solving is an approach where learners explore a
problem or a task and their responses to the task are ‘orchestrated’ by the teacher to introduce
and develop the mathematics to be learned. The development of this teaching approach
involves the principles of task design and planning the sequencing of anticipated responses to
be orchestrated.
The professional development programme was informed by research on task design and the
features of effective professional learning for teachers. The programme was built around the
professional learning programme Lesson Study and was modified with a ‘pause’ in the
research lesson and the use of remote visualisers to observe and analyse the work of the
pupils. This latter feature was an adaption of the original programme design to respond to
conditions arising in schools during the Covid-19 pandemic. Also a number of additional
modifications were made to accommodate the ambitions of the programme.
A qualitative approach was adopted using the methodology of design research and
comprising two research cycles. The cohort in the first cycle were secondary school teachers
and in the second cycle they were primary school teachers, all working in England. The aim
of the study was to understand the effect of the programme on the participants’ knowledge,
skills and confidence in teaching mathematics through problem solving. Existing frameworks
in the literature on the known characteristics of effective professional learning were
synthesised to evaluate the effectiveness of the programme.
The main outcomes from this research confirm that the designed features of the PD
programme were effective in supporting teachers in developing their ability to teach
mathematics through problem solving. The use of task design principles in conjunction with
the development of the teaching technique of orchestration resulted in gains in teacher
confidence and subject and pedagogical knowledge. The pause in the research lesson and the
use of visualisers to observe and analyse the pupils’ work provided the participants with a
focused learning opportunity to develop the teaching approach. The evaluation of the
programme using the designed analytical framework for CPD identified [a range of] known
characteristics of effective CPD in the programme as designed and implemented.
Three main implications emerged from the study, the first of which concerns the future
development of teaching mathematics through problem solving. It was apparent that there
were contextual barriers to the approach becoming an established part of teachers’ practice.
To address these, the design of mathematics teaching resources would need to reflect the
ambition to teach mathematics through problem solving. This is an issue for curriculum
designers. There would also need to be recognition of the problem-solving skills that pupils
require to access the problems, which would need to be taught either as part of teaching
through problem solving or as a separate approach known as teaching for problem solving.
The second implication identifies the challenges associated with introducing this type of
programme into the current landscape of professional learning for teachers of mathematics in
England, including the need for greater coherence between the professional learning of
teachers of mathematics and their own workplace contexts.
Finally, the third implication relates to the use of Lesson Study. This study described how the
use of design research can develop Lesson Study variants that can make a positive
contribution to professional learning environments for teachers without compromising the
key principles of Lesson Study.
More Information
Statistics
Downloads
Downloads per month over past year
Metrics
Altmetric Badge
Dimensions Badge
Share
Actions (login required)
View Item |