COSTELLO, Amanda Jane (2020). Stories of female special school headteachers and their experience of headship: an interpretative phenomenological analysis. Doctoral, Sheffield Hallam University. [Thesis]
Documents
27860:564547
PDF
Costello_2020_EdD_StoriesFemaleSpecial.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives.
Costello_2020_EdD_StoriesFemaleSpecial.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives.
Download (6MB) | Preview
Abstract
Leadership positions in special schools are becoming increasingly difficult to
fill and there is a significant gap in the literature on special school leadership
in general. This gap in the research includes a focus on the life stories of
female headteachers in these settings and situated within a constructivist
paradigm. Taking a narrative approach, this study will explore the life stories
of female special school headteachers, building on an understanding of their
leadership journey in order to potentially act as an inspiration to others.
Detailing different aspects of the special school headteachers’ experiences,
the themes highlighted the complexity of the women’s impressions of special
school headship, the heterogeneity among the special school headteacher
stories and the importance of critical reflection within their journey.
Unstructured interviews were conducted with six participants. All interview
transcripts were analysed using Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis
(IPA). Three subordinate themes emerged from the data: ‘managing
constraint’, ‘motivating forces’ and ‘perceptions of special school headship
and the future’.
Drawing on Giddens’ theory of social forces and his belief about the primacy
of human knowledgeability over social forces, and also Margaret Archer’s
theory of reflexivity as an intercessor between structural forces and human
agency, this thesis proposes three types of special school headteacher: ‘the
strategic and decisive leader’, ‘the values-orientated professional’ and ‘the
person-centred educator’. These ideal types illustrate the heterogeneous
ways in which a small sample of women special school headteachers had
reflected on, positioned themselves towards and navigated their way through
the career challenges in special education. This typology together with the
nuanced analysis advanced throughout this thesis offers a unique
contribution to knowledge. The varying inferences for special school practice
4
and research were discussed and I conclude by arguing that the underrepresentation of women in special school headship is a complex situation,
and the stories of special school headteachers merit a place at the centre of
our theorising and understanding of it.
The findings reported in this thesis may be of interest to potential special
school headteacher aspirants, as well as those tasked with identifying and
training future special school leaders.
More Information
Statistics
Downloads
Downloads per month over past year
Metrics
Altmetric Badge
Dimensions Badge
Share
Actions (login required)
View Item |