O'DONNELL, Michael (2019). Educational Inequality: Race, Schools and Urban Development in Phoenix; 1968-1982. Doctoral, Sheffield Hallam University.
Documents
27223:557485
PDF
O'Donnell_2019_PhD_EducationalInequalityRace.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives.
O'Donnell_2019_PhD_EducationalInequalityRace.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives.
Download (1MB) | Preview
Abstract
This thesis argues that to understand why bilingual education did not achieve its aims, the
program must be analysed within an urban history context of residential and school
segregation in Phoenix. When passed by Congress in 1968, the Bilingual Education Act (BEA)
was considered the signature civil rights achievement for Latinos of that era. Ten years later,
bilingual education was increasingly considered ineffectual and failed to effect a meaningful
change in the attainment gap between Latinos and their Anglo classmates, as was the main
objective of the BEA 1968.
By focusing upon Phoenix, Arizona between 1968 and 1982, this thesis argues that bilingual
education and the place of Mexican Americans in the southwest was fundamentally contested
in ways that historians have not fully captured in previous works. This thesis contributes to
knowledge by showing that unlike in other Sunbelt locations, in Arizona bilingual education
was opposed by conservative politicians throughout this period and its survival remained
uncertain. Although hopes for accessing the opportunities granted by Great Society legislation
were curtailed by this opposition, it was a series of urban development, school site selection
and school desegregation policies which undermined the effectiveness of Phoenix schools in
ways that bilingual education could not remedy. These policies created an unequal
metropolitan landscape that was reflected in the increasingly racially imbalanced enrolments
in Phoenix schools. Ultimately, they caused the closure of inner-city high schools and, by 1982,
the creation of a thirty square mile radius without a school.
This narrative of underlying discrimination against Mexican Americans also contributes to
knowledge by challenging the contemporary marketing of Phoenix as a modern, racially
tolerant city. In many cases, Mexican Americans were subject to many of the same prejudiced
practices that African Americans were subject to in other Sunbelt cities. Yet, some Mexican
American public figures were able to escape the worst excesses of racism. This thesis,
therefore, examines the complex environment in which Mexican American racial identities
evolved during this period, as the community attempted to navigate the challenges of race4
making state practices and the opportunities that the introduction of bilingual education
brought with it.
More Information
Statistics
Downloads
Downloads per month over past year
Metrics
Altmetric Badge
Dimensions Badge
Share
Actions (login required)
![]() |
View Item |