"Two sides of the same coin"? Coaching and mentoring and the agentic role of context

STOKES, Paul, FATIEN DIOCHON, Pauline and OTTER, Ken (2020). "Two sides of the same coin"? Coaching and mentoring and the agentic role of context. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

Preview	PDF Stokes_Two_Sides_of_(AM).pdf - Accepted Version All rights reserved. Download (226kB) | Preview
Preview	PDF (Figure 1) Stokes_Two_Sides_of_(Supp).pdf - Supplemental Material All rights reserved. Download (25kB) | Preview

Abstract

Our article depicts and interrogates the claims for seeing coaching and mentoring as being distinct from each other, and rather suggests that context is agentic in determining which aspects of these two helping orientations are likely to be used by practitioners. To start with, our article traces the development of coaching and mentoring as two separate discourses. Traditionally, coaching has been associated with a shorter term performance focus, with the coach portrayed as a process‐ rather than a content knowledge−based expert. By contrast, mentoring has a longer‐term holistic focus, where the mentor has direct experience and knowledge in the setting that the mentee is operating in. Then, we discuss some limitations of seeking conceptual distinctiveness in purely theoretical terms, including accentuating differences of practices that cannot easily be disentangled from each other in practice. Therefore, on the basis of a case study, where coaching and mentoring behaviors are used by leaders and managers, we argue that context plays an agentic role and influences which of the helping orientations is used by practitioners. We conclude that, context being multifaceted, it leads to a kaleidoscope of coaching/mentoring behaviors, which supports a practice‐based approach to the debate.

Item Type:	Article
Uncontrolled Keywords:	General Science & Technology
Identification Number:	https://doi.org/10.1111/nyas.14316
SWORD Depositor:	Symplectic Elements
Depositing User:	Symplectic Elements
Date Deposited:	29 Jan 2020 11:31
Last Modified:	17 Mar 2021 14:46
URI:	https://shura.shu.ac.uk/id/eprint/25754

Actions (login required)

View Item

Downloads

Publication Metrics